Skip to Content

How Long is Pot Roast Good For and Other Frequently Asked Questions About Pot Roast

These answers to frequently asked questions about pot roast will help you make the perfect meal with very little effort. You’ll love the way it turns out every time you make it.

Whether you cook pot roast in an Instant Pot, cook it in a pressure cooker, or use a slow cooking method, you can make any type of roast delicious. Or if you prefer, cook it in a Dutch oven on top of the stove or in the oven.

Roast beef is a popular comfort food, and there are quite a few great recipes you can try.

plate of juicy pot roast

One easy recipe we like is this delicious Mississippi Crock Pot Roast. In fact, it’s one of our favorite slow cooker recipes We like this one just as much the next day or even the day after that.

This slow cooker pot roast is a favorite go-to meal when I want to cook something that doesn’t take long to prepare. All you need is a few minutes to put everything into the pot in the morning. Then just walk away and come back hours later to a delicious home-cooked meal.

Perfect Pot Roast

It’s easy to make the perfect pot roast for any style of serving it. You just have to know which cuts are suited to what you want to do with it.

A good pot roast can also be a delicious part of a one pot meal. Simply add some potatoes and vegetables during the cooking process, and you have a complete meal. Another benefit is that you’ll only have one pot or pan to clean.

pot of raw roast with green beans, potatoes, carrots, and onions

These answers to frequently asked questions about pot roast will eliminate a lot of headaches when cooking your favorite comfort meal. And your family will ask for it often.

How Long is Pot Roast Good For?

A cooked pot roast keeps in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. It might still taste okay after that, but it’s always a good idea to be safe when it comes to food.

If your pot roast recipe calls for ingredients that spoil more quickly, such as anything with cream or milk, keep that in mind. However, if you’re using gravy with beef stock, it should be good for the full 5 days.

What Is the Best Meat for Pot Roast?

Before deciding which cut of beef roast to purchase, you need to determine how you plan to serve it. Do you want to shred it, slice it, or cut it into bite-size pieces?

If you want the meat to easily fall apart, consider a boneless chuck roast that comes from the shoulder of the cow. This is a favorite cut for shredding when you want to add sauce for sandwiches. It’s also good for topping mashed potatoes and rice.

A shoulder roast that comes from the shoulder section of the cow, right above the short rib, is tender and juicy. This is an affordable cut of meat that is often on sale at meat markets and grocery stores.

A round roast is ideal for slicing because it’s lean and holds together throughout the cooking process. It looks nice when sliced and placed on a serving platter along with vegetables cooked in the pan juices.

slicing roast beef

Another delicious option is a roast beef brisket that can be sliced or shredded. It has more fat than the round roast.

What Makes a Pot Roast Tough?

One of the most frequently asked questions about pot roast is what makes it so tough. Roast that has a lot of connective tissue and collagen, such as a bottom round roast, is typically one of the tougher cuts of meat. A rump roast contains quite a bit less fat and marbling.

A tough cut of meat can still be good, so don’t overlook it while shopping. There to turn tough meat into tender meat with the right cooking process.

How Do You Keep Pot Roast from Getting Tough?

When a roast has lots of connective tissue, you’ll need to take extra care in cooking it. Otherwise, it will be chewy and possibly inedible.

Two of the best ways to keep pot roast from getting too tough are slow cooking or pressure cooking it. Between the two methods, I prefer slow cooking if I have the time. However, it’s just as good in the Instant pot on high pressure.

You can also use a meat tenderizer. I recommend marinating it in a mixture of a bromelain based tenderizer and Worcestershire sauce for a long period of time, like overnight. In addition to making it tender, it adds a tremendous amount of flavor.

Why Is My Pot Roast Not Falling Apart?

If you want your roast so tender it falls apart, you need to cook it long enough … but not too long. Cooking time may vary, but you’ll typically be safe with a medium or large (3 pound roast or larger) roast in the slow cooker on a low temperature for 6-8 hours.

tender, juicy meat that's falling apart

How Do You Make a Tough Pot Roast Tender?

If your roast isn’t done enough it will have a dense texture that feels like leather. On the flip side, a roast that is overdone will appear dry and flaky.

For an underdone roast, add more liquid to the pot and cook it some more. Give it at least another hour and check it. 

When the roast is overdone, it’s still salvageable. The best thing to do is add more liquid such as beef broth and shred it. Stir the meat into the broth until all of the fibers are coated. 

What is the Best Way to Serve Sliced Pot Roast?

Before you slice your pot roast, allow it to rest on a plate at room temperature for at least 15-20 minutes. I like to loosely drape a sheet of aluminum foil over the top during this process. This allows the juices to settle down without running out of the meat, making it dry.

I like to serve a sliced juicy pot roast with potatoes, carrots, green beans, and onions that I’ve cooked with the meat. Every bite is loaded with delicious beef flavor that is so satisfying and comforting.

plate of sliced pot roast with vegetables

More Delicious Slow Cooker Recipes

As a fan of slow cooking, I have several Crock Pots in different sizes. Here are some more of our favorite slow cooker recipes:

Chicken and Gravy Over Mashed Potatoes – This is always a hit with a side of steamed vegetables or a tossed salad.

Crock Pot Garlic Tomato Roast Beef – We love this melt in your mouth tender dish that’s packed with flavor.

Slow Cooker Pork Tenderloin – Next time you get a pork tenderloin, try this recipe. It will quickly become one of your favorites.

Slow Cooker Ham and Pineapple Glaze – You’ll love the blend of flavors in this yummy meal from Julia’s Simply Southern.

Crock Pot Hawaiian Chicken – Every single bite of this delicious dish is like a vacation in the mouth!

Other ingredients you may want to add to any pot roast are fresh thyme, bay leaves, black pepper, or a cup of red wine.

If you want to try other seasonings, don’t be afraid. You might discover your favorite way of cooking roast by using spices you use in other dishes.

plate of sliced meat beside pot of meat and vegetables

What Can You Do with Leftover Pot Roast?

The last of my frequently asked questions about pot roast is what to do with the leftovers. This one is my favorite because there are so many things you can do.

I like to cook enough roast for leftovers. You can make so many different meals with leftover roast. Here are some of our favorites:

Add barbecue sauce to shredded roast and make sandwiches.

Chop up the roast and make this yummy beef hash.

Shred or chop the beef and add it to soups, stews, or marinara sauce.

Please feel free to share!